50 Amazing Christmas Cookie Recipes

LAST UPDATED: Dec 05, 2019 | PUBLISHED: Nov 03, 2019 | By: Julie Blanner

All the best, easy, Christmas Cookie Recipes and decorating tips for your annual Christmas Cookie bake day or holiday party. Fill your cookie jar with festive homemade cookies, frosted and decorated for the holiday season.meringues with sugar coated cranberries and mint leaves to look like festive christmas cookies on a white platter

50 christmas cookie recipes - cookies decorated with sugar covered berries and mint leaves

Every holiday has its own fun and bit of magic, but Christmas truly is the most wonderful time of the year where traditions are celebrated and memories are made.  It’s a time to gather our loved ones, amend differences, be extra charitable, and remember our blessings. 

The Best Christmas Cookies

Baking Christmas cookies is definitely one of my favorite traditions. Maybe my favorite! I love to gather with my girls in the kitchen baking up tasty treats to fill the cookie jar.

Christmas cookies make wonderful gifts for teachers, neighbors, and friends. The beauty of the holidays is that there is something for everyone. If baking cookies isn’t your thing, I’m sure we can all get on board with eating them! 

I’m going to share with you my best tips for baking Christmas Cookies. I’ve included tools, frequently used ingredients (so you can stock up, if desired!)  and of course, my most requested, and favorite Christmas Cookie recipes and holiday treats.

All these Christmas Cookie recipes are so easy to make, festive and delicious! You can also find some of my favorite cookie frosting recipes, toppings, decorating tips and ideas. 

meringues decorated with sugared cranberries and mint leaves on a platter

Christmas Cookie Recipes

Christmas Cookies are always a favorite. It’s the time of year when I take a little extra time to add a bit of sparkle to each cookie.

Sugar Cookies are one of our favorite Christmas Cookie Recipes – they are always fun to make with kids, too! The girls love to help me make frosting and decorate them. The options are endless and each cookie is it’s own work of art.

If you ever feel overwhelmed by building a gingerbread house or cutting out gingerbread men, I have the perfect solution! Create a Sugar Cookie Candy House! It’s so simple and SO much fun! It’s a great Christmas activity without the fuss!

girl decorating christmas cookie sugar cookie cake gingerbread house

Peanut butter and chocolate is a classic combination and you’ll find my buckeye recipe to satisfy even the most sweet tooth.

Easy Christmas Cookies

Most of my Christmas Cookie Recipes are so easy to make and require only a few staple ingredients. Chocolate chip, meringue, and kitchen sink cookies, to name a few can be made up in a matter of minutes and then baked, cooled, and are ready to serve! 

No-bake cookies are another favorite and always a huge hit at holiday gatherings. If I’m planning a cookie bake day, I always have a few no-bake cookie recipes in my list as they can help save on oven space and time.

Christmas Cookie Decorations

During the holidays, I love to add a little extra flair to my Christmas Cookie recipes. I like to embellish my cookies with decorations. Sometimes I’ve gone all out and other times I’ve taken a more simple route and with adding elegant coarse sugar crystals, lightly sprinkled on top as in my white chocolate cookies. It adds a delicate sparkle for the finishing touch. 

Everyone I know loves a frosted and decorated cookie. Christmas cookie frosting is so delicious and smooth. It’s the heavenly last touch, and finishing topping on an already perfect cookie! 

I love a creamy white icing for elegant and fancier christmas gatherings. For a more relaxed event or decorating with children try adding a bit of red or green food coloring to your icing. 

Melted chocolate is a perfect finishing touch for cookies. You can drizzle over finished cookies or dip your baked and cooled cookies into the melted chocolate. You can even finish with a few sprinkles.

However, if you prefer, I have an array of Christmas Cookie Recipes that don’t require any decorating!

Frosting Recipes

Sprinkles and Toppings

  • Coarse Sugar 
  • Colored Sprinkles
  • Candies 
  • Crushed Peppermint Candies
  • Mini Chocolate Chips
  • Chopped Nuts (pecans, walnuts, peanuts, almonds)
  • Coconut 
  • Candied Fruit
  • Sugared Fruit
  • Hershey Kisses
  • Powdered Sugar

eggnog cookies covered in powdered sugar on baking sheet next to two cups of eggnog a mixer and prelit garland

Christmas Cookie Baking Tips

elf on the shelf next to miniature elf cookies

  • Cookies only take a few minutes to bake. The time range is usually 7-10 minutes. The less time in the oven produces a more gooey cookie and more time equals a cruncher cookie. Testing your oven temperature and baking time with a pre batch of only 1 or 2 cookies before baking the entire batch will ensure the rest of the cookie batch is perfect!
  • Most ingredients, including refrigerated items such as eggs and butter should be brought to room temperature before using in your recipe.
  • Measure ingredients accurately, using liquid and dry ingredient measuring cups. 
  • Level off dry ingredients using the dull side of a knife. This will ensure an exact amount without packing down your ingredient. 
  • Read through your recipe beforehand to allow time for chilling, baking, and cooling your cookies. 

You can sign up to receive my Best Baking Tips here!

Storing Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies typically store quite well. A Christmas tin or tupperware work perfectly as storage containers. Fresh cookies will last at room temperature for about 3 days.

Cookies can also be frozen. Shortbread and SugarCookies freeze especially well well. Use parchment to layer undecorated cookies in a freezer safe bag. Freeze up to 3 months. 

Frozen cookies can be removed from the freezer and allowed to thaw at room temperature outside of their bag or container for several hours. Cookies can also be microwaved to speed up defrosting.

Shipping Christmas Cookies

boxes to gift wrap and ship cookies

  • Choose wisely – some cookies ship better than others, like shortbreads, sugar cookies, etc.
  • Use food safe materials. Parchment paper is easy to cut to fit any box and of course, food safe.
  • Choose sturdy materials. If they need to be airtight, use tins.
  • Package your cookies inside a box, then fill a second box with packing material, insert the box and surround it with packing material.
  • Don’t skimp on the packing supplies. Save peanuts, bubble wrap, etc to ensure that the box inside the box won’t move.
  • Ship USPS Priority. It’s quick, reasonable and can deliver anywhere…even military bases. Lesson learned.

You can get more details on how to ship cookies here.

Baking Tools

Cookie baking doesn’t require many kitchen appliances or utensils, but a few well chosen ones are definitely helpful. I’ve outlined my favorites below as well as some alternatives!

It is me or is baking even more fun with beautiful bakeware?

Staple Ingredients for Baking Christmas Cookies

Stock up on these staple ingredients for all of your favorite Christmas Cookie recipes so that you can bake them up on a whim!

Dry Ingredients

  • White Flour
  • Granulated White Sugar
  • Brown Sugar
  • Powdered Sugar (also called Confectioners Sugar)
  • Course Ground Sugar Granules 
  • Baking Soda
  • Baking Powder
  • Cream of Tartar
  • Salt
  • Ginger
  • Cinnamon
  • Allspice
  • Nutmeg

Wet Ingredients

Cold Ingredients

  • Butter (salted and unsalted)
  • Cream Cheese

Specialty Ingredients

  • Cocoa Powder
  • Chocolate Chips
  • Chocolate Peppermint Chips
  • Peanut Butter Chips
  • White Chocolate Chips
  • Sprinkles
  • Shortening
  • Candies 
  • Nuts
  • Peppermint Extract 
  • Butter extract
  • Maple Extract 
  • Almond Extract
  • Orange Extract
  • Cranberries
  • Orange Zest

50 Amazing Christmas Cookie Recipes

All the best, easy, Christmas Cookie Recipes and decorating tips for your annual Christmas Cookie bake day or holiday party. Fill your cookie jar with festive homemade cookies, frosted and decorated for the holiday season. 

I hope you enjoy all of these Christmas Cookie recipes! I can’t wait to hear which one is YOUR favorite!

Disclosure