Learn How to Soften Butter Quickly With These Tricks

LAST UPDATED: Mar 04, 2020 | PUBLISHED: Feb 03, 2020 | By: Julie Blanner

Get the best tips and tricks to soften butter quickly. We’ll take that cold, hard butter and bring it to the perfect room temperature. With these simple methods to warm your butter, you’ll soon be warming hearts with your baking.

Learn how to soften butter with a rolling pin on a marble surface.

As Julia Child said, “With enough butter, anything is good.”  I believe that with all my heart. That’s the reason why I have made butter a staple ingredient in our home! 

During my weekly trip to the supermarket, I always make sure to stock up on salted butter. I can store the extra in my freezer until I’m ready to use. This way, I am never out of butter and have to make a special trip.

However, this can create a little dilemma if I forget to defrost the butter! I’ve shared with you my best tips to quickly softening cream cheese and now I want to share with you how to quickly soften butter. 

A stick of wrapped salted butter on a marble surface. 

Why Soften Butter Before Starting Your Recipe

Most, if not all baking recipes call for softened butter or room temperature butter. Softened butter allows you to mix or cream butter together with the other ingredients in your recipe.

To achieve perfect bakery quality desserts and smooth creamy frostings, I’ve found these tips to be the most impactful in my baking! 

Did you know that softened butter isn’t just a suggestion in baking… it’s actually a requirement? The temperature of your butter is so significant that many recipes will fail without that perfect room temperature required to trap the air into the fat itself. This is the absolutely imperative to the process of creaming. 

A stick of unwrapped salted butter on a marble surface.

How to Soften Butter – 5 Easy Methods

Leave Out On The Counter Method

First things first, you can leave salted butter out on the counter (covered) overnight to defrost and soften. This may surprise you, but leaving salted butter out on the counter overnight is perfectly safe.

Some safety experts say it is a matter of preference whether to refrigerate salted butter or not. Personally, I definitely err on the side of refrigeration for long term storage. However, I do believe allowing your butter to rest at room temperature is the best method for softening overall! 

If you are trying to defrost frozen butter, this method is best.

A white plate on a white surface, stick of butter in the center.

Unsalted butter can also be left out for a few hours to soften as well. Without the preservative of salt though, unsalted butter should be refrigerated after a few hours or frozen for longer storage. 

This method does take about 12 hours and is not convenient if you are in a hurry. 

How to Soften Butter in the Microwave Method

The microwave is probably the fastest way to soften butter, especially if it is frozen. In my option, it is also the hardest method. The microwave has so much power that usually the result is melted butter or unevenly softened butter. I do have a few tips though. 

  • Place butter in a microwave safe bowl, and place the bowl in the microwave.
  • Microwave for 3 seconds.
  • Rotate butter and microwave again for 3 seconds.
  • Do this until your butter is completely softened. 

Time consuming? Perhaps, but it’s still a much faster method to reaching your goal! 

White plate with a stick of butter inside microwave.

Sliced Butter Method

If you’ve just taken your stick of butter out of the fridge (not freezer) you can cut the stick into slices and leave in a sunny spot for about 30 minutes. It will soften perfectly for baking. 

A white surface, with a white plate full of cuts of cold butter.

Another option is to use a box grater. Run your cold butter across the largest side of the grater. This grates the butter in large chunks which is perfect for softening quickly. This method will cut your softening time in about half.

A pile of shredded butter.

Again… isn’t this image incredibly satisfying? Or maybe that’s just me. The butter love runs deep! 

A pile of shredded butter on a white platter..

Rolling Pin Method

Lay your stick of butter between two sheets of wax paper and use your rolling pin to flatten the butter to about ¼ inch. At this point, the butter should be softened enough to use.

 

Let’s be honest, it’s also a lot of fun and super satisfying to see that beautiful butter flattened out perfectly on your counter top! 

Learn how to soften butter with a rolling pin on a marble surface.

Water Bath Method 

Another easy trick is to give your butter a hot water bath. 

  • Simply heat up some water to boiling or almost boiling in a medium size pot.
  • Using a high heat safe glass bowl, place butter into bowl.
  • Place the butter bowl on top of your pot with hot water creating a double broiler.
  • For even faster softening time, use a lid on top of the butter bowl. 

This method can soften your butter fairly quickly. Slice your butter for even faster results.

A white surface, with a white plate full of cuts of cold butter.

 

A Few Favorite Recipes with Butter

Now that your butter is perfect, it is time to bake! Try out my best bakery quality cookie recipes.

  • M&M Cookies – These M&M cookies are just delicious. I share some of my best cookie tips with this recipe so you don’t want to miss out!
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake – Thick chewy cookie cake with chocolate chips and a secret twist you’ll love! A classic cookie cake recipe you’ll make time and again! 
  • Kitchen Sink Cookies – These cookies are full of delicousness. Stuffed with crunchy pretzels, toffee, and chocolate chips for the perfect sweet and salty balance! 
  • Cinnamon Sugar Cookies – I created this recipe for the holidays but it is a huge hit all year long! A wintery twist on the classic sugar cookie recipe, this recipe won’t disappoint no matter when you serve them!
  • Caramel Frosting – You’ll wonder why you ever bought icing from the store after you make this easy frosting recipe. Caramel icing is smooth and creamy and tastes divine. 
  • Buttercream Frosting for Sugar Cookies – The best cookie frosting recipe ever! Flavorful and smooth, it is so easy to ice and decorate your cookies with this buttercream!

Psst… have you tried my delicious honey butter? Don’t skip it- it’s so delicious to slather on virtually everything you can dream of! 

Marble surface, stick of butter and rolling pin.

More of the Best Baking Tips

  • Brown Butter – Learn how to brown butter with this recipe and video tutorial. Browning butter is often overlooked or skipped in recipes, but you will see here how it could be the secret to bakery quality desserts!
  • How to Soften Cream Cheese – In a pinch? Learn how to soften cream cheese quickly and safely! 
  • Essential Measurement Conversion Chart – Adjust your recipes without effort! Hang this chart inside your cabinet for quick reference.

Flattened butter on a marble surface.

A white surface, with a white plate full of cuts of cold butter.

How to Soften Butter

Yield: 1 Cup
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Cook Time: 25 minutes
Additional Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 35 minutes

How to Quickly Soften Butter

Ingredients

  • 1 Cup Butter

Instructions

  1. Microwave Butter on high for 3 seconds.
  2. Rotate butter and microwave again.
  3. Repeat until soft.

Notes

Alternative Methods

  • Frozen salted butter can be left out on the counter to defrost for 12 hours.
  • Place butter between 2 sheets of wax paper. Using a rolling pin, roll out butter to 1/4 inch thickness.
  • Create a double broiler and put butter in dish over a pot of hot water. Use a lid to help trap heat in the bowl containing the butter.

Disclosure